It depends on the angle your cat works at, not on which is better. Cats that reach up want a post. Cats that scratch at waist height on furniture edges want a board. Watch where the damage is and buy to match it.
What is a cat scratch board? A flat or angled panel with a scratching surface fixed to it, meant to lean or sit instead of standing upright. Boards suit corners and furniture edges. Posts suit cats that stretch vertically.
How long does a sisal cat scratcher last? Longer than cardboard, though how much longer depends entirely on the cat. Sisal fibre wears down slowly instead of tearing away, which is why it makes so much less mess as it goes.
Where to put a cat scratch board: against the thing being scratched. Behind a sofa, the side of an armchair, a door frame, or near where your cat sleeps. Boards fail when they are put somewhere tidy.
The best cat scratching board for most homes is one that fits the angle of the damage. Shape matters more than brand here.
Is sisal better than cardboard for scratching? Neither, they do different jobs. Sisal wears slowly and sheds almost nothing. Cardboard gives way more readily and most cats prefer it for lying-down scratching. Households with one cat often end up owning both.
A corner cat scratcher only works if the corner is one your cat already uses. Buying the shape without checking the location is the usual mistake.